The 2024 Ballon d'Or ceremony concluded with Rodri emerging as the biggest winner, though Real Madrid claimed awards for Best Club, Best Coach, and Best Forward. In a notable absence, Real Madrid chose to boycott the event in response to not winning the Best Player award, despite considerable anticipation for Vinicius as a frontrunner. Even after Rodri’s European Cup victory, Vinicius remained a popular pick for Best Player, though he ultimately did not secure the title, which, while surprising, was not entirely unexpected.

The Ballon d'Or selection criteria have three primary aspects. First, the selection cycle now follows a seasonal timeline rather than a calendar year. Second, a candidate must have substantial achievements as a team’s core player, with a strong showing on and off the field. Vinicius, as Real Madrid's attacking leader, contributed to the Champions League, La Liga, and Spanish Super Cup titles last season, meeting the first two criteria.

Rodri, however, matched these achievements, securing the Premier League, UEFA Super Cup, and Club World Cup with Manchester City. Additionally, he led Spain as a key midfielder in their European Cup victory, accumulating impressive personal stats, with nine goals and 14 assists. The deciding factor lay in the third criterion: sportsmanship and professionalism on the field.

Vinicius’s undeniable skill as one of football’s top wingers has sometimes been overshadowed by his contentious interactions. Known for verbal and physical clashes and outspoken remarks, his behavior occasionally leaves fans divided. The Ballon d'Or seeks an “idol-level” player, and while Vinicius’s talent is unquestionable, his temperament may not fit this image.

Ultimately, Vinicius's exclusion may be due less to his skills and more to his need for restraint. With greater composure, he might secure more support and elevate his standing in future Ballon d'Or nominations.